Say your family home is worth $500,000 and you sell it to buy a smaller place for $70,000 less. How much of that $70,000 actually lands in your pocket?

About $27,500. Less than half. And that's before a couple of costs that only show up once you've moved in.

Downsizing in retirement is part of a lot of plans, and I think it's one of the easiest parts to get wrong, because the mistakes tend to stay invisible until the closing table. I've been buying and selling houses for over 12 years and own a couple dozen rentals today, so I've sat through a lot of closings. Here are the seven mistakes I'd watch for, each with a number attached.

Where the $70,000 goes

Mistake one: assuming a smaller house costs a lot less. Nationally, it usually doesn't. According to the National Association of Realtors, the median single-family home sold for $422,700 in September. The median condo sold for $363,700. That's only about 14% cheaper. You give up the yard, the garage and a couple of bedrooms for roughly a seventh off the price.

Moving across town doesn't change much either. In the Realtors' 2025 survey of buyers and sellers, the typical seller moved just 30 miles. So plenty of people buy in the same market they sold in, at about the same prices. Sell a $500,000 house, stay nearby, and a place 14% cheaper runs about $430,000. That's the $70,000 gap.

Mistake two: forgetting what it costs to sell. The listing price is not the check you get.

Broker commissions still run about 5.5% nationally once you add both sides, and the seller usually pays them. The seller's other closing costs add about 2.7% on top. On a $500,000 house, that's $27,500 in commissions and $13,500 in closing costs. $41,000 gone before you've bought anything.

Interestingly, Clever Real Estate's breakdown shows most of that 2.7% isn't a fee at all. It's money the seller hands the buyer for repairs, their closing costs, or a lower mortgage rate. Redfin says sellers gave buyers that kind of help in 44.7% of US home sales in August. So almost half the time, the contract price isn't quite what you keep.

Then you pay for the move. A local move averaged $1,489 in This Old House's 2025 survey, so call it $1,500.

Add it up: $500,000, minus $41,000 to sell, minus $430,000 for the new place, minus $1,500 for movers. You're left with about $27,500, before your own closing costs on the new place.

A cheaper house can come with a bigger tax bill

Mistake three: resetting your property taxes. This one depends heavily on your state, so it's worth reading even if you don't live in the two below.

In California, a home's assessed value generally can't rise more than 2% a year while you own it, no matter how fast prices climb. In Florida, a homestead's assessed value is capped at 3% a year, or inflation if that's lower. Live somewhere like that for 20 years and your tax bill is probably based on a value far below today's price.

The problem: the new place gets assessed at what you paid for it. You can move into a cheaper house and end up with a bigger property tax bill.

Both states have a way around this. In California, Prop 19 lets homeowners 55 and older carry their old tax value to a new home anywhere in the state, up to three times. In Florida it's called portability: you can carry the gap between your capped value and market value, up to $500,000 of it, to your new homestead. Both come with deadlines, so learn them before you sell.

Anywhere else, I'd call your county assessor before listing. Some states cap assessments and some don't, and the call is free.

The HOA bill never gets paid off

Mistake four: ignoring the HOA fee. Plenty of condos and 55-plus communities come with one.

The Census Bureau says owners with no mortgage who pay an HOA or condo fee paid a median of $184 a month in 2024. Across everyone paying those fees, about three million households pay more than $500 a month.

Even at the median, that's $2,208 a year you never paid in your old house, and it comes straight out of whatever you hoped to save. When I compare two places, I treat an HOA fee like a mortgage payment. To your budget it works the same way, except it never gets paid off. Usually it just goes up.

The home sale tax break has an old ceiling

Mistake five: assuming the home sale exclusion covers you. I think it carries more fine print than people expect.

If you've owned and lived in the house for two of the last five years, you can exclude $250,000 of profit from tax if you're single, or $500,000 if you're married filing jointly. The catch: those limits were set in 1997 and have never been raised. Meanwhile the median new home went from about $145,000 back then to $410,000 this spring.

On a real house: say you bought your $500,000 home for $150,000. Selling costs come off first, so what you actually got is $459,000, and your profit is $309,000. Married, you're under the cap and owe nothing. Single, $59,000 of that gain is taxable, and at a 15% rate that's about $8,850 in federal tax. The more your house has appreciated and the longer you've owned it, the bigger that number gets, because the limit doesn't grow with it.

Mistake six: throwing away the receipts. Every improvement you've made (a new roof, an addition, a remodeled kitchen) gets added to what you paid for the house. If that single seller put $59,000 into improvements and can prove it, the profit drops to $250,000 and the tax drops to zero.

Only improvements count, not repairs. A new roof counts. Patching a leak doesn't. And without paperwork, any of it is hard to prove. I'd start a folder now, even if selling is 10 years out. It's probably the easiest money on this whole list.

Downsize for the monthly bill, not the cash

Mistake seven, and I think the biggest: downsizing for the cash instead of a lower monthly bill.

When I decide whether to sell a house, I ask what the money will do once it's out. I recently sold one of my rentals for exactly that reason. About $100,000 of equity was sitting in it, producing something like $300 to $400 a month in cash flow. That money could do more for me elsewhere.

Ask the same question here. If only about $27,500 comes back to you, I don't think the cash is a good reason to move. It has to be about the monthly number.

In our example, selling and moving cost about $42,500. If the smaller place saves you $500 a month in taxes, insurance, utilities and upkeep, it takes about seven years just to earn back the cost of moving. Save $1,000 a month and it's about three and a half.

So downsizing really pays when it cuts your monthly costs by a lot. It also pays when you move somewhere much cheaper, because the gap between regions is big. The median home in the West sold for $613,600 in September. In the Midwest it was $329,600. A move like that changes the math completely.

And sometimes it isn't about money at all. Maybe you're just done with the stairs or the yard. That's a perfectly good reason, as long as you know what it costs.