Whether to pay off your mortgage before retirement usually gets argued as a question about interest rates. I think that's the wrong place to start. A paid-off house pays you something like $1,200 a month, and you'll never see it on a statement.
That sounds strange if you're still working and mailing a payment every month. Right now your house probably feels like the opposite of retirement money. But look at what the Census Bureau found when it tracked monthly housing costs. In 2024, the typical homeowner with a mortgage spent $2,035 a month on the house, counting property taxes, insurance and utilities. The typical homeowner with no mortgage spent $664.
That's roughly $1,370 a month that stops leaving the house. These are two different groups of people, so it's a rough comparison. Still, it shows you how much changes once the loan is gone.
Price your house like a rental
I own a couple dozen rental properties, and I price every one of them the same way. First question: what would someone pay to live there? Then I subtract what I'd be stuck paying as the owner no matter what. Property taxes, insurance, repairs. Whatever's left is what the house actually earns.
So let's run an ordinary American home through it.
The median existing home sold for $429,100 this August. A typical three-bedroom rents for about $2,100 a month. Where you live moves that number a lot. It's closer to $1,750 in the Midwest and more like $3,195 on the Pacific Coast. We'll stick with $2,100.
Now the subtractions. Property taxes run about 0.9% of a home's value per year nationally, so around $3,860 here. Insurance is hard to pin down because it depends so much on your state, but call it $2,000 to $2,500 a year. Repairs are usually budgeted at 1% of the home's value, about $4,300, because sooner or later you're replacing the roof and the furnace.
Add it up and the owner's costs come to roughly $870 a month. Take that out of $2,100 and you're left with about $1,200 a month.
Nobody mails you that money. You get it as rent you never pay, for as long as you live there. It isn't taxed, because there's no income for the IRS to see. And it tracks local rents, not the stock market.
The house versus the same money invested
The obvious follow-up: how does that compare to having the money in the market instead?
Say the $429,100 sat in your 401(k), and you lived off it by selling 4% a year. That's about $17,160 a year, or $1,430 a month before tax. In the 22% bracket, it's more like $1,115 a month after federal tax.
So they land pretty close. The more interesting part is that each one does something the other can't.
Nobody sells off your house at the bottom of a crash, and you never have to decide how much to take. The $1,200 shows up whether the market is up 20% or down 30%. But it only pays you in one form. You can't buy groceries with it, and when a big bill lands, you can't sell 4% of your house.
Invested money is the reverse. You can spend it on anything, any month you like, but its value changes every day the market is open.
My first real lesson in what a small housing bill does came from an Ohio duplex. I bought it with a VA loan, lived in one unit, and rented the upstairs. My payment, taxes and insurance came to about $1,300 a month. The tenant paid $950. So I was living there for about $350 a month, and for the first time in my life I had a real amount of money left over at the end of the month.
A paid-off house does basically the same thing in retirement. Housing is often the biggest chunk of what American households spend, and you just took it off the table.
When the mortgage outlives the paycheck
If you're still earning, this part changes how much you need to save.
Say you plan to retire at 57, but the mortgage runs until 67, and the payment is $2,000 a month. That's $24,000 a year. Over 10 years, it's $240,000 your savings has to cover now that no paycheck is covering it.
If that money comes out of a 401(k), taxes come out on top. In the 22% bracket, you'd have to withdraw about $308,000 to walk away with $240,000. That's $308,000 that could have kept growing for the rest of your retirement. A loan that's gone before you stop working never costs your savings a dime.
So my take is that the day your mortgage ends is one of the biggest dates in your plan. Every year it runs past your last paycheck, your savings pays for it.
The health insurance cliff before 65
This one catches people off guard if they stop working before 65. Until Medicare, you're buying your own health insurance, and if you buy a plan yourself, you can get help paying for it based on your income.
Congress made that help bigger in 2021. The bigger version expired when 2025 ended. The House voted in January to bring it back, but the Senate still hasn't, so we're planning under the old rules. And the old rules have a cliff in them.
For next year's coverage, a couple's help disappears completely once their income goes over about $86,500. Just under the line, the subsidies are very good. One dollar over, and you lose all of it.
Here's the catch: whatever you take out of your 401(k) counts as income. Every withdrawal pushes you closer to the line.
Picture a couple, both 60, on the standard silver plan. They spend $5,500 a month with their health plan included, and the house is paid off. They pull $70,000 a year from their 401(k), which leaves about $5,500 a month after federal taxes. They're under the line, so they get about $24,700 a year toward their health plan. So far, so good.
Now give them a $2,000 mortgage on top of that. To cover it, they have to pull about $97,000 a year. Now they're over the line. The subsidy is gone, and they pay the full premium of around $31,800 a year at this year's average price.
Count the payments, the extra tax and the lost help, and that mortgage is costing them more than $50,000 a year, every year until they turn 65. These subsidy rules can change, and they're hard to plan around. But under today's rules, that's the real price of keeping the loan.
The backup you already own
There's one more thing a paid-off house does that I don't think gets enough credit. It's a backup if something goes wrong later.
When you sell your main home, up to $250,000 of the profit is tax free if you're single, or $500,000 if you're married filing jointly, as long as you've owned it and lived there for two of the past five years. So if you ever really need the money, you can sell, buy something smaller and pocket the difference, often with no tax on the gain.
And if you're 62 or older, a reverse mortgage lets you get at that money without moving. It comes with some real costs, though, so understand them before you go that route.
Two numbers and two dates
You can run all of this on your own house tonight.
Find out what a house like yours rents for where you live, and multiply by 12. Subtract a year of property taxes and insurance, plus repairs at about 1% of the home's value. Divide by 12. That's roughly what your house pays you once it's paid off.
Then write down two dates: the month your mortgage ends and the month you'd like to stop working. If the mortgage ends after you want to stop, write down the payment too. Every $1,000 a month still running after your last paycheck is $12,000 a year your savings has to cover, before tax.