← All Letters November 10, 2026

The roof that cancelled a health insurance subsidy

If you retire before 65, a new roof can cost you your health insurance subsidy.

Here's how.

Picture a couple who retire at 62. They buy their own health plan on the marketplace, and a subsidy called the premium tax credit pays most of it. That subsidy depends on their income, so they keep their 401(k) withdrawals to about $75,000.

In September the furnace quits. It's 24 years old. The installer says the roof is done too.

Call it $20,000 for both. It comes out of the traditional 401(k), and every dollar of it counts as income. With the tax on top, their income goes well past $90,000.

Under 2026 rules, the subsidy doesn't shrink a little at a time. Once a couple's income passes about $84,600, it's gone completely. And because it was paid to the insurer all year, they find out in April, when their tax return makes them pay all of it back. For a couple in their early 60s, that can easily be more than $10,000.

The repairs cost $20,000. The year they happened in cost them a lot more.

A house is a list of parts, and each one has an expiration date. The furnace didn't surprise them. The timing did.

So while the paycheck is still coming in, find out how old your roof, furnace, AC, water heater and windows are. Replace anything close to the end now, one or two a year, and pay for it out of salary. You're not spending more money. You're choosing which year the bill lands in.

So here's my question: if your furnace quit the month after your last paycheck, which account would pay for it, and what would that withdrawal do to the rest of your year?

Hit reply and tell me.
Get The Letter

One short letter, every Tuesday.

A single email each week on building retirement income outside the stock market. Short enough to read with your coffee.