← All Letters November 3, 2026

The seller who never got a tenant call

In April 2023 we bought a three-bedroom house in Parma, Ohio, for $139,000.

A month later a family moved in on a lease option. They rented the house, and they had the right to buy it at a fixed price of $179,000.

Two years later, they bought it. They signed the purchase agreement in May 2025, and the sale closed about a week after that.

That's how we run our deals. We look for people who want to be owners, not tenants, and we give them a way to get there. Not every family makes it all the way. This one did.

But the part I keep coming back to isn't the family. It's the seller.

When we bought the house, the seller didn't get one check for the full price. They financed it themselves. So instead of a house, they held a note on it, and we made the payments to them.

Think about what those two years were like for them.

They didn't screen the family. They didn't handle a repair or chase a rent payment. Anything to do with the house came to us. What they had was a payment owed to them every month, with a house behind it. When the family bought the house, the sale paid their note off in full.

That's what it's like to hold a note instead of being a landlord.

I've done both. I own rentals and I hold a note myself. A rental is an okay middle ground if you don't mind vacancies, turnover and maintenance calls, but those never really stop. With a note I do the work once, up front: the house, the title, the person I'm lending to. After that, I'm not the one getting the calls.

Most of you have the opposite setup. Your money is in the stock market, and the plan is to sell shares every month once the paycheck stops. That can work. It just means your income depends on what the market will pay for your shares that month. A note works differently. Someone owes you a payment, and a house secures it.

Like every investment, a note carries risk. Your money is committed for the term, it isn't FDIC-insured, and if a borrower stops paying, getting your money back goes through the house, which takes time.

The seller in Parma got the version where everything worked. The family wanted the house, they bought it, and the note got paid.

So here's my question: if you could own the house or hold the note on it, which would you pick, and why?

Just reply and tell me.
Get The Letter

One short letter, every Tuesday.

A single email each week on building retirement income outside the stock market. Short enough to read with your coffee.